Chicago Storm (GB)

51 runs · 5 wins (9.8%) · 11 placed (21.6%)
Trainer: Barry Murtagh Owner: Hurst Farm Racing Sire: Dabirsim Dam: Hoh My Darling Damsire: Dansili Sex: gelding Colour: b Foaled: 15 Feb 2019 Bred in: GB
Swipe sideways to see the whole tree →
HorseChicago Storm (GB)SireDabirsimDamHoh My DarlingDamsireDansili
Flat
8139Aug 2023Nov 2026OR: 67 -- Guinness 0.0 Handicap (50-70) (03 Aug 23)OR: 65 -- Treo Eile Retraining Ireland's Racehorses Handicap (47-70) (21 Sep 23)OR: 64 -- Galway Races Summer Festival 2024 Handicap (47-65) (Div 1) (30 Oct 23)OR: 63 -- Put The Fun In Fundraising At Dundalk Handicap (47-70) (01 Mar 24)OR: 62 -- QuinnBet Handicap (18 Mar 24)OR: 62 -- NSL Investments Handicap (47-65) (24 Mar 24)OR: 61 -- PG Duffy & Sons Citroen Handicap (21 Apr 24)OR: 59 -- Corinthian Challenge Charity Race Series (21 Jul 24)OR: 58 -- Hartes Group Apprentice Handicap (Div 1) (25 Aug 24)OR: 63 -- Glenroyal Hotel Student Derby Handicap (28 Sep 24)OR: 62 -- Torc Travel Handicap (07 Oct 24)OR: 61 -- TRM - From Ireland To The World Apprentice Handicap (47-75) (13 Oct 24)OR: 60 -- businessplus.ie Handicap (03 Nov 24)OR: 58 -- Christmas Party Nights At Dundalk Stadium Claiming Race (11 Dec 24)OR: 65 -- Havana Grey Standing At Whitsbury Manor Handicap (20 Apr 25)OR: 65 -- Unibet 3 Uniboosts A Day Handicap (15 Oct 25)OR: 64 -- Create Your Bet Builders At Midnite Handicap (27 Jan 26)OR: 63 -- Make The Move To Midnite Handicap (28 Feb 26)OR: 67 -- Create Your Bet Builders At Midnite Handicap (02 Apr 26)OR: 66 -- Make The Move To Midnite Handicap Stakes (Div I) (21 Nov 26)Speed: 81 -- Guinness 0.0 Handicap (50-70) (03 Aug 23)Speed: 67 -- Treo Eile Retraining Ireland's Racehorses Handicap (47-70) (21 Sep 23)Speed: 51 -- Galway Races Summer Festival 2024 Handicap (47-65) (Div 1) (30 Oct 23)Speed: 63 -- Put The Fun In Fundraising At Dundalk Handicap (47-70) (01 Mar 24)Speed: 67 -- QuinnBet Handicap (18 Mar 24)Speed: 57 -- NSL Investments Handicap (47-65) (24 Mar 24)Speed: 65 -- PG Duffy & Sons Citroen Handicap (21 Apr 24)Speed: 71 -- Corinthian Challenge Charity Race Series (21 Jul 24)Speed: 71 -- Hartes Group Apprentice Handicap (Div 1) (25 Aug 24)Speed: 70 -- Glenroyal Hotel Student Derby Handicap (28 Sep 24)Speed: 71 -- Torc Travel Handicap (07 Oct 24)Speed: 53 -- TRM - From Ireland To The World Apprentice Handicap (47-75) (13 Oct 24)Speed: 64 -- businessplus.ie Handicap (03 Nov 24)Speed: 52 -- Christmas Party Nights At Dundalk Stadium Claiming Race (11 Dec 24)Speed: 55 -- Havana Grey Standing At Whitsbury Manor Handicap (20 Apr 25)Speed: 50 -- Make The Move To Midnite Handicap Stakes (Div I) (21 Nov 26)Perf: 63 -- Guinness 0.0 Handicap (50-70) (03 Aug 23)Perf: 65 -- Treo Eile Retraining Ireland's Racehorses Handicap (47-70) (21 Sep 23)Perf: 68 -- Galway Races Summer Festival 2024 Handicap (47-65) (Div 1) (30 Oct 23)Perf: 60 -- Put The Fun In Fundraising At Dundalk Handicap (47-70) (01 Mar 24)Perf: 70 -- QuinnBet Handicap (18 Mar 24)Perf: 61 -- NSL Investments Handicap (47-65) (24 Mar 24)Perf: 52 -- PG Duffy & Sons Citroen Handicap (21 Apr 24)Perf: 56 -- Corinthian Challenge Charity Race Series (21 Jul 24)Perf: 60 -- Hartes Group Apprentice Handicap (Div 1) (25 Aug 24)Perf: 58 -- Glenroyal Hotel Student Derby Handicap (28 Sep 24)Perf: 60 -- Torc Travel Handicap (07 Oct 24)Perf: 39 -- TRM - From Ireland To The World Apprentice Handicap (47-75) (13 Oct 24)Perf: 54 -- businessplus.ie Handicap (03 Nov 24)Perf: 72 -- Christmas Party Nights At Dundalk Stadium Claiming Race (11 Dec 24)Perf: 61 -- Havana Grey Standing At Whitsbury Manor Handicap (20 Apr 25)Perf: 49 -- Make The Move To Midnite Handicap Stakes (Div I) (21 Nov 26)ORSpeedPerf
Jumps
11591Sep 2023Nov 2026OR: 98 -- Roche's Feeds Handicap Hurdle (80-102) (27 Dec 23)OR: 97 -- Kanturk Handicap Hurdle (80-109) (05 Aug 24)OR: 95 -- Gaeil Colmcille GAA Kells 'Day At The Races' Handicap Hurdle (80-102) (17 Nov 24)OR: 98 -- 90 January & February Hospitality Offer Handicap Hurdle (16 Jan 25)OR: 106 -- Join The 20 Club At Huntingdon Novices' Handicap Hurdle (GBB Race) (06 Feb 25)OR: 108 -- Aston Villa Foundation Handicap Hurdle (21 Feb 25)OR: 108 -- DragonBet Supporting UK Racecourses Handicap Hurdle (10 Mar 25)OR: 113 -- Maundy Thursday Evening Meeting 17th April Handicap Hurdle (25 Mar 25)OR: 113 -- Weatherbys ePassport Handicap Hurdle (10 Jun 25)OR: 113 -- FBC Manby Bowdler Handicap Hurdle (18 Jun 25)OR: 111 -- Oddschecker Handicap Hurdle (07 Nov 25)OR: 110 -- PricedUp The Jumps Novices' Handicap Chase (GBB Race) (20 Nov 25)OR: 108 -- EK Mowers And Machinery Novices' Handicap Chase (GBB Race) (03 Dec 25)OR: 105 -- Download The PricedUp App Handicap Hurdle (26 Dec 25)OR: 103 -- Bet At racingtv.com Handicap Hurdle (19 Apr 26)OR: 100 -- Tileform Handicap Chase (13 Jun 26)OR: 95 -- Race Home With Genesis Homes Handicap Hurdle Race (Div I) (22 Oct 26)OR: 92 -- Canine PREMIER FLEX Plus Joint Supplement Etc Handicap Hurdle Race (Go North Sea Pigeon Series Qualifier) (03 Nov 26)Perf: 100 -- Boyle Maiden Hurdle (25 Sep 23)Perf: 92 -- King John's Castle Maiden Hurdle (21 Oct 23)Perf: 91 -- Roche's Feeds Handicap Hurdle (80-102) (27 Dec 23)Perf: 106 -- 90 January & February Hospitality Offer Handicap Hurdle (16 Jan 25)Perf: 108 -- Join The 20 Club At Huntingdon Novices' Handicap Hurdle (GBB Race) (06 Feb 25)Perf: 107 -- Aston Villa Foundation Handicap Hurdle (21 Feb 25)Perf: 115 -- DragonBet Supporting UK Racecourses Handicap Hurdle (10 Mar 25)Perf: 111 -- Maundy Thursday Evening Meeting 17th April Handicap Hurdle (25 Mar 25)Perf: 107 -- Weatherbys ePassport Handicap Hurdle (10 Jun 25)Perf: 112 -- FBC Manby Bowdler Handicap Hurdle (18 Jun 25)ORSpeedPerf
OR = official rating (the handicapper's figure). Perf and Speed = performance and speed ratings supplied by our data provider; not every run has one.
Record
A/E = wins divided by the wins its starting prices suggested (margin removed): above 1.00 means it has won more often than the market expected. Green ▲ or red ▼ only when clearly above or below; * = fewer than 5 wins expected, so read it lightly; a dash means too few runs for A/E to mean anything. P/L at SP = profit from 1 point on every run. Placed = finished 1st, 2nd or 3rd.
RunsWinsPlacedA/EP/L at SP
Career51 5 (10%) 11 1.34* +26.50
By distance
DistanceRunsWinsPlacedA/EP/L at SP
7f3 0 (0%) 1 – -3.00
1m2 0 (0%) 0 – -2.00
1m1f1 0 (0%) 1 – -1.00
1m2f8 1 (12%) 3 – +13.00
1m3f4 1 (25%) 1 – +8.00
1m4f8 1 (12%) 1 – +4.00
1m5f2 0 (0%) 0 – -2.00
1m6f2 0 (0%) 0 – -2.00
1m7f2 1 (50%) 1 – +24.00
2m12 0 (0%) 1 – -12.00
2m1f1 0 (0%) 0 – -1.00
2m2f3 0 (0%) 1 – -3.00
2m3f2 1 (50%) 1 – +4.50
2m4f1 0 (0%) 0 – -1.00
By going
GoingRunsWinsPlacedA/EP/L at SP
Good14 0 (0%) 1 – -14.00
Standard8 2 (25%) 2 – +16.00
Heavy7 0 (0%) 1 – -7.00
Good To Soft5 2 (40%) 3 – +27.50
Yielding5 0 (0%) 2 – -5.00
Good To Yielding4 1 (25%) 1 – +17.00
Soft3 0 (0%) 0 – -3.00
Soft To Heavy2 0 (0%) 0 – -2.00
Standard To Slow1 0 (0%) 0 – -1.00
Good To Firm1 0 (0%) 1 – -1.00
Yielding To Soft1 0 (0%) 0 – -1.00
By class
ClassRunsWinsPlacedA/EP/L at SP
Class 410 1 (10%) 2 0.80* -3.50
Class 58 1 (12%) 3 – +18.00
Class 63 1 (33%) 1 – +9.00
No class30 2 (7%) 5 1.13* +3.00
By course
CourseRunsWinsPlacedA/EP/L at SP
Curragh5 0 (0%) 0 – -5.00
Dundalk4 1 (25%) 1 – +8.00
Wincanton3 1 (33%) 1 – +23.00
Naas3 1 (33%) 2 – +18.00
Stratford2 1 (50%) 2 – +4.50
Southwell2 1 (50%) 1 – +10.00
Navan2 0 (0%) 0 – -2.00
Limerick2 0 (0%) 0 – -2.00
Gowran Park2 0 (0%) 0 – -2.00
Galway2 0 (0%) 0 – -2.00
Roscommon2 0 (0%) 0 – -2.00
Ballinrobe2 0 (0%) 1 – -2.00
Newcastle1 0 (0%) 0 – -1.00
Sedgefield1 0 (0%) 0 – -1.00
Carlisle1 0 (0%) 0 – -1.00
Hexham1 0 (0%) 0 – -1.00
Wolverhampton1 0 (0%) 0 – -1.00
Ludlow1 0 (0%) 0 – -1.00
Exeter1 0 (0%) 0 – -1.00
Kempton1 0 (0%) 0 – -1.00
Worcester1 0 (0%) 0 – -1.00
Fontwell1 0 (0%) 0 – -1.00
Bath1 0 (0%) 1 – -1.00
Taunton1 0 (0%) 0 – -1.00
Warwick1 0 (0%) 0 – -1.00
Huntingdon1 0 (0%) 1 – -1.00
Killarney1 0 (0%) 0 – -1.00
Cork1 0 (0%) 0 – -1.00
Listowel1 0 (0%) 0 – -1.00
Fairyhouse1 0 (0%) 0 – -1.00
Sligo1 0 (0%) 0 – -1.00
Down Royal1 0 (0%) 1 – -1.00
By race type
Race typeRunsWinsPlacedA/EP/L at SP
Flat, handicap19 2 (11%) 4 1.38* +14.00
Hurdle, handicap15 2 (13%) 4 1.63* +17.50
Flat, non-handicap11 1 (9%) 3 – +1.00
Chase, handicap3 0 (0%) 0 – -3.00
Hurdle, non-handicap3 0 (0%) 0 – -3.00
By headgear
HeadgearRunsWinsPlacedA/EP/L at SP
None32 4 (12%) 8 1.72* +24.50
cheekpieces5 0 (0%) 0 – -5.00
visor3 0 (0%) 1 – -3.00
tongue tie + cheekpieces8 1 (12%) 2 – +13.00
tongue tie + visor1 0 (0%) 0 – -1.00
tongue tie1 0 (0%) 0 – -1.00
blinkers1 0 (0%) 0 – -1.00
By days since last run
Days since last runRunsWinsPlacedA/EP/L at SP
First run1 0 (0%) 0 – -1.00
Up to 14 days14 0 (0%) 1 – -14.00
15-30 days21 3 (14%) 7 1.64* +18.50
31-60 days10 2 (20%) 3 – +28.00
61-120 days3 0 (0%) 0 – -3.00
121+ days2 0 (0%) 0 – -2.00
Date Course Race Pos Btn SP OR Jockey / Trainer
21 Nov 26 Newcastle
Class 5 · 1m4½f · Standard · Drawn 6 · 9-7
7 5½ 150/1 66 Amie Waugh
Barry Murtagh

Hurst Farm Racing
Prominent early - pushed along 2f out - faded inside the final furlong
03 Nov 26 Sedgefield
Class 5 · 2m1f · Good · cheekpieces · 11-6
PU - 125/1 92 Lorcan Murtagh
Barry Murtagh

Hurst Farm Racing
close up early - dropped away before 5th and soon well adrift - eased and pulled up before the second last
22 Oct 26 Carlisle
Class 5 · 2m4f · Good · 11-9
13 3¼ 150/1 95 Lorcan Murtagh
F P Murtagh

Hurst Farm Racing
Settled in the pack's back half - went to the tail after 3 out - soon well adrift and finished 13th
13 Jun 26 Hexham
Class 5 · 1m7½f · Good · 12-0
PU - 20/1 100 Lorcan Murtagh
Barry Murtagh

Hurst Farm Racing
19 Apr 26 Stratford
Class 5 · 2m2½f · Good · 11-8
3 7½ 11/1 103 Beau Morgan
Daisy Hitchins

Simonell Racing
In touch with leaders on outer - went third 6th - no impression before last(op 7/1)
02 Apr 26 Southwell
Class 5 · 1m3f · Standard · Drawn 3 · 9-2
6 3 5/1 67 Millie Wonnacott
Daisy Hitchins

Simonell Racing
Led - headed and prominent after 1f - pressed leaders over 1f out - weakened inside final furlong(op 9/2 tchd 4/1)
28 Feb 26 Southwell
Class 6 · 1m3f · Standard · Drawn 8 · 9-3
1 11/1 63 Millie Wonnacott
Daisy Hitchins

Simonell Racing
Midfield but raced wide early - in touch with leaders after 2f - headway to lead 2f out - kept on inside final furlong(op 16/1)
27 Jan 26 Wolverhampton
Class 6 · 1m6f · Standard · Drawn 5 · 9-8
4 ¾ 11/1 64 Jack Nicholls
Daisy Hitchins

Simonell Racing
Towards rear - headway on outer over 2f out - bumped and carried right on turn over 1f out - ridden inside final furlong - kept on inside final 110yds - not reach leaders(tchd 10/1)
26 Dec 25 Wincanton
Class 4 · 1m7f · Good To Soft · visor · 11-2
11 31 17/2 105 Robbie David
Daisy Hitchins

Simonell Racing
Midfield - weakened home turn - tailed off(op 14/1 tchd 8/1)
03 Dec 25 Ludlow
Class 4 · 2m · Good To Soft · cheekpieces · 11-5
F - 5/1 108 Robbie David
Daisy Hitchins

Simonell Racing
In rear - headway 5th - lost position and reminder when slow jump 6th - mistake 8th - 6 lengths fifth when fell 4 out(op 11/2 tchd 9/2 and tchd 6/1)
20 Nov 25 Wincanton
Class 4 · 1m7½f · Good · cheekpieces · 11-5
5 ½ 12/1 110 Robbie David
Daisy Hitchins

Simonell Racing
Pressed leaders - slightly hampered 3 out - weakened 2 out - lost fourth run-in
07 Nov 25 Exeter
Class 4 · 2m½f · Good · 11-8
8 4¼ 12/1 111 Robbie David
Daisy Hitchins

Miss Daisy Hitchins
Midfield - not fluent 3rd - soon reminder then in touch with leaders - disputing third 3 out - weakened 2 out(tchd 14/1)
15 Oct 25 Kempton
Class 6 · 1m4f · Standard To Slow · Drawn 9 · 9-9
5 2¼ 22/1 65 Oliver Carmichael
Daisy Hitchins

Miss Daisy Hitchins
In rear - headway from over 1f out - kept on inside final furlong(op 20/1 tchd 16/1)
18 Jun 25 Worcester
Class 4 · 2m · Good · cheekpieces · 11-3
4 2½ 12/1 113 Robbie David
Daisy Hitchins

Miss Daisy Hitchins
10 Jun 25 Fontwell
Class 4 · 2m1f162y · Good · 11-7
4 1 3/1 113 Robbie David
Daisy Hitchins

Miss Daisy Hitchins
20 Apr 25 Bath
Class 5 · 1m2f37y · Good To Firm · Drawn 7 · 8-13
3 1 3/1 65 Trevor Whelan
Daisy Hitchins

Miss Daisy Hitchins
25 Mar 25 Taunton
Class 4 · 2m3f1y · Good · 11-3
4 3 9/2 113 Robbie David
Daisy Hitchins

Miss Daisy Hitchins
10 Mar 25 Stratford
Class 4 · 2m2f148y · Good To Soft · 11-5
1 11/2 108 Robbie David
Daisy Hitchins

Miss Daisy Hitchins
21 Feb 25 Warwick
Class 4 · 2m · Soft · 11-7
5 1½ 5/1 108 Robbie David
Daisy Hitchins

Miss Daisy Hitchins
06 Feb 25 Huntingdon
Class 4 · 1m7f171y · Good To Soft · 11-3
2 2¼ 7/2 106 Robbie David
Daisy Hitchins

Miss Daisy Hitchins
16 Jan 25 Wincanton
Class 5 · 1m7f50y · Good To Soft · 11-5
1 25/1 98 Mr Robbie David
Daisy Hitchins

Miss Daisy Hitchins
11 Dec 24 Dundalk
1m4f · Standard · Drawn 4 · 9-2
1 11/1 58 Colin Keane
Chris Timmons

Tony Carey Martin W Walsh
17 Nov 24 Navan
2m · Yielding · tongue tie + cheekpieces · 11-7
15 nk 80/1 95 Daniel King
Chris Timmons

Tony Carey Martin W Walsh
03 Nov 24 Curragh
7f · Yielding To Soft · Drawn 10 · tongue tie + visor · 8-4
19 hd 66/1 60 Siobhan Rutledge
Chris Timmons

Tony Carey Martin W Walsh
13 Oct 24 Naas
1m2f84y · Yielding · Drawn 13 · tongue tie + cheekpieces · 9-0
9 3 13/2 61 Alexandra Egan
Chris Timmons

Tony Carey Martin W Walsh
07 Oct 24 Killarney
1m30y · Heavy · Drawn 1 · tongue tie + cheekpieces · 8-7
4 nse 8/1 62 Wayne Lordan
Chris Timmons

Anthony Carey Martin W Walsh
28 Sep 24 Curragh
1m2f · Good · Drawn 6 · tongue tie + cheekpieces · 10-12
7 1¾ 9/1 63 Miss A Jones
Chris Timmons

Anthony Carey Martin W Walsh
25 Aug 24 Naas
1m2f84y · Good To Yielding · Drawn 14 · tongue tie + cheekpieces · 8-11
1 20/1 58 Jack Cleary
Chris Timmons

Anthony Carey Martin W Walsh
05 Aug 24 Cork
2m2f100y · Good To Yielding · 11-2
13 2¼ 25/1 97 Kevin Sexton
Chris Timmons

Anthony Carey Martin W Walsh
21 Jul 24 Curragh
1m4f · Good · tongue tie · 12-0
7 4¼ 22/1 59 Brian Mulvey
Chris Timmons

Anthony Carey Martin W Walsh
21 Apr 24 Curragh
7f · Soft To Heavy · Drawn 17 · tongue tie + cheekpieces · 8-9
12 ½ 4/1 61 David Egan
Chris Timmons

Anthony Carey Martin W Walsh Derek Dunne
24 Mar 24 Naas
7f · Heavy · Drawn 4 · tongue tie + cheekpieces · 10-2
3 5 4/1 62 Ben Coen
Chris Timmons

Anthony Carey Martin W Walsh Derek Dunne
18 Mar 24 Curragh
1m · Heavy · Drawn 9 · tongue tie + cheekpieces · 8-13
5 nk 14/1 62 Sorcha Woods
Chris Timmons

Anthony Carey Martin W Walsh Derek Dunne
01 Mar 24 Dundalk
1m4f · Standard · Drawn 4 · blinkers · 9-11
7 1¾ 14/1 63 Gary Halpin
Chris Timmons

Anthony Carey Martin W Walsh Derek Dunne
27 Dec 23 Limerick
2m · Heavy · 11-5
6 3 16/1 98 Gavin Brouder
Peter Fahey

Anthony Carey Martin W Walsh Derek Dunne
11 Nov 23 Gowran Park
2m · Heavy · 11-7
11 1 9/1 Ricky Doyle
Peter Fahey

Anthony Carey Martin W Walsh Derek Dunne
30 Oct 23 Galway
1m3f180y · Heavy · Drawn 16 · 9-12
4 ½ 11/1 64 Scott McCullagh
Peter Fahey

Anthony Carey Martin W Walsh Derek Dunne
21 Oct 23 Limerick
2m · Heavy · 11-7
6 1½ 12/1 Sean Flanagan
Peter Fahey

Anthony Carey Martin W Walsh Derek Dunne
25 Sep 23 Roscommon
1m7f195y · Soft · 11-7
5 ¾ 33/1 Kevin Sexton
Peter Fahey

Anthony Carey Martin W Walsh Derek Dunne
21 Sep 23 Listowel
1m6f55y · Soft To Heavy · Drawn 1 · 9-6
5 shd 20/1 65 Paddy Harnett
Peter Fahey

Anthony Carey Martin W Walsh Derek Dunne
03 Aug 23 Galway
1m4f · Yielding · Drawn 4 · 9-13
6 1½ 33/1 67 Ben Coen
Peter Fahey

Anthony Carey Conor Brett Derek Dunne M W Walsh
24 Jul 23 Ballinrobe
1m1f96y · Yielding · Drawn 9 · 9-3
3 6 11/2 69 Scott McCullagh
Peter Fahey

G F Oneill
04 Jul 23 Roscommon
1m4f · Good To Yielding · Drawn 3 · 9-6
9 1¾ 40/1 69 Scott McCullagh
Peter Fahey

G F Oneill
26 Jun 23 Ballinrobe
1m1f125y · Good · Drawn 5 · cheekpieces · 9-9
5 4 11/1 71 Ben Coen
Peter Fahey

G F Oneill
01 Jun 23 Fairyhouse
1m2f · Good · Drawn 12 · 9-7
10 nk 14/1 73 Danny Gilligan
Peter Fahey

G F Oneill
16 May 23 Sligo
1m5f40y · Good To Yielding · Drawn 11 · 10-7
5 2¾ 18/1 74 Colin Keane
Peter Fahey

G F Oneill
18 Apr 23 Gowran Park
1m1f130y · Soft · Drawn 16 · 9-9
5 1¼ 25/1 72 Ben Coen
Peter Fahey

G F Oneill
12 Jul 22 Dundalk
1m2f150y · Standard · Drawn 4 · visor · 9-8
7 5 7/1 75 Ben Coen
J P Murtagh

Anthony Paul Smurfit Samuel M Mencoff
18 Jun 22 Down Royal
1m2f75y · Yielding · Drawn 6 · visor · 9-8
3 1 12/1 Ben Coen
J P Murtagh

Anthony Paul Smurfit Samuel M Mencoff
23 Apr 22 Navan
1m5f · Good · Drawn 11 · 9-8
8 14 66/1 Shane B Kelly
J P Murtagh

Anthony Paul Smurfit Samuel M Mencoff
01 Apr 22 Dundalk
1m2f150y · Standard · Drawn 5 · 9-8
4 1½ 14/1 Ben Coen
J P Murtagh

Anthony Paul Smurfit Samuel M Mencoff