Flat Handicap Disagreement (EV > 0)

The same disagreement test as above, run specifically on Flat handicaps -- the segment with the most historical validation, now being tested forward on live races.

Settlement note: from 8 October 2026 every bet on this page is a straight win bet, because the strategy backs the model's top pick to win, and all earlier bets have been re-settled the same way so the record is consistent. Before that date, picks priced above 4/1 were settled each-way.

-61.97% ROI
7.7% Strike rate
-24.17 Total profit
39.0 Total staked
39 3W 0P 36L · 1 void
0 Open bets
Our price compared withBetsMedian CLVAverage CLVBeat price
Bookmaker SP, same-day prices (from 6 Oct 2026) 10 +0.0% +2.2% 40%
Bookmaker SP, all bets 39 +4.5% -2.6% 51%
Betfair SP, same-day prices (from 6 Oct 2026) 10 -16.0% -12.2% 10%
Betfair SP, all bets 38 -18.3% -18.1% 21%
Betfair SP vs the typical runner at the same price, same-day 10 +0.9% +6.6% 60%

Compares the price we logged with the price the market closed at: a positive figure means we took a better price than the market closed at. It is an early sign of whether the model finds real value, well before profit and loss settles down, but small samples swing a lot. Betfair SP is a sharper benchmark than the bookmaker starting price (bookmaker prices carry a margin, especially on longer-priced horses) and is shown before Betfair commission, so every runner normally looks negative against it and the gap widens with the price. The "typical runner" row corrects for that: it compares each bet with the average runner in the same price band (under 4, 4 to 8, 8 to 15, 15 plus) since 6 October, in percentage points, so a positive figure means the model's picks closed better than a typical horse at that price. Bets logged before 6 October 2026 could be logged the evening before, on thinner early prices, so they are shown separately.

Drawdowns, losing runs and months the bad spells as well as the good, from 39 settled bets

Worked out from the bets as logged (level stakes, void bets left out), in race order. A drawdown is the biggest fall in running profit from a previous high point. An each-way bet that placed but still lost money counts as a losing bet. Losing runs this long or longer can happen again, whatever the results so far.

Worst drawdown −24.17 units 24 Sep 2026 to 15 Oct 2026 · not yet back to that high
Below its best −24.17 units best running profit so far: +0.00 units
Longest run without a winner 18 bets 02 Oct to 15 Oct 2026 · current run: 18
Longest run of losing bets 18 bets 02 Oct to 15 Oct 2026 · current run: 18
MonthBetsWinsStakedProfitROIRunning profit
Oct 2026 22 2 22.00 -11.67 -53.0% -24.17
Sep 2026 17 1 17.00 -12.50 -73.5% -12.50
Weekly results profit and ROI for each week (Monday to Sunday), by race date

Each row is one week of settled bets. ROI is profit divided by units staked that week. A single week is a small sample and swings a lot, so look at the cumulative ROI column for the longer picture. The current week is still in progress. Void bets are not counted.

WeekBetsWinsStakedProfitROICumulative ROI
12 Oct – 18 Oct 4 0 4.00 -4.00 -100.0% -62.0%
05 Oct – 11 Oct 10 0 10.00 -10.00 -100.0% -57.6%
28 Sep – 04 Oct 17 3 17.00 -2.17 -12.8% -40.7%
21 Sep – 27 Sep 8 0 8.00 -8.00 -100.0% -100.0%
Staking simulator flat staking against Kelly staking on this strategy's 39 settled bets

This replays the settled bets in race order starting with a bankroll of 100 units, using the results exactly as they were settled. Flat staking puts 1 unit on every bet. Kelly staking puts a share of the current bankroll on each bet, sized by how much value the model saw in it (expected value ÷ (odds − 1)), so bigger edges get bigger stakes and the stakes grow and shrink with the bankroll. Quarter and half Kelly use a quarter or half of that share, which is how Kelly is usually used because full Kelly swings a lot. No single bet is capped above 10% of the bankroll. Bets the model rated at zero or negative value get no Kelly stake: 26 of 39 bets here had positive expected value. Each-way bets use the same formula as an approximation, and bets that overlapped on the same day are treated as one after another. With a small number of bets, the result mostly shows how lucky or unlucky the run was, not which staking plan is better.

7286100114129StartBet 39
Staking planBets stakedFinal bankrollChangeBiggest drop
Flat staking (1 unit a bet) 39 75.8 -24.2% -24%
Quarter Kelly 26 98.5 -1.5% -8%
Half Kelly 26 95.8 -4.2% -16%
Full Kelly 26 87.9 -12.1% -30%

Why Kelly can lose more than flat staking. Kelly stakes more when the model sees more value. When the model's edge is overstated, the biggest stakes go on the bets where the model is most wrong, and losses compound: a bankroll that falls by half has to double just to get back to where it started. That is why we judge every method at flat stakes.

0.0-24.2Sep 26Oct 26Running: -1.00 (this bet: -1.00) -- Starakova, Weekend Winners On At The Races Handicap Stakes (24 Sep 26)Running: -2.00 (this bet: -1.00) -- Mr Noble, Christopher Ward Watchmaking Handicap Stakes (25 Sep 26)Running: -3.00 (this bet: -1.00) -- Asia Force, By Eck Its Boddingtons Handicap Stakes (gbbplus Race) (25 Sep 26)Running: -4.00 (this bet: -1.00) -- Sword Maker, Hunt Family Fund Handicap Stakes (25 Sep 26)Running: -5.00 (this bet: -1.00) -- Let's Go Hugo, Gent's Night Sat 24th October Handicap Stakes (26 Sep 26)Running: -6.00 (this bet: -1.00) -- Madjid, Tipsy Tapas At Winter Ladies Evening Handicap Stakes (26 Sep 26)Running: -7.00 (this bet: -1.00) -- Crown Office, Betfred 'The Classic Bookmaker' Handicap Stakes (26 Sep 26)Running: -8.00 (this bet: -1.00) -- The Ginger Kid, Betfred 'Turbo Boost' Nursery Handicap Stakes (27 Sep 26)Running: -4.50 (this bet: +3.50) -- Darkest Red, Matchbook Monthly Bet-Builder Rebate Handicap Stakes (27 Sep 26)Running: -5.50 (this bet: -1.00) -- Gallant Lion, Matchbook Monthly Bet-Builder Rebate Handicap Stakes (28 Sep 26)Running: -6.50 (this bet: -1.00) -- Henfield, Hotel & Conferencing At Wolverhampton Handicap Stakes (28 Sep 26)Running: -7.50 (this bet: -1.00) -- Army Bugler, Clyde And Co Handicap Stakes (Div II) (28 Sep 26)Running: -8.50 (this bet: -1.00) -- Izenterisky (A), Carbonnetzero Handicap Stakes (Arab Race) (28 Sep 26)Running: -9.50 (this bet: -1.00) -- Keep An Eye On It, Nairns's Oatcakes Handicap Stakes (GBBPlus Race) (29 Sep 26)Running: -10.50 (this bet: -1.00) -- Decalogue, Jdl Consultants Ltd Apprentice Handicap Stakes (29 Sep 26)Running: -11.50 (this bet: -1.00) -- Riddikulus, Join Racing Tv Now Handicap Stakes (30 Sep 26)Running: -12.50 (this bet: -1.00) -- Rock Steady Beat, Dropkicks Split The G Nursery Handicap Stakes (30 Sep 26)Running: -13.50 (this bet: -1.00) -- Washington Royale, Racedays For £9 At Nottingham Racecourse Nursery Handicap Stakes (01 Oct 26)Running: -8.50 (this bet: +5.00) -- Regional Rock, Sandown Kia Salisbury Handicap Stakes (01 Oct 26)Running: -9.50 (this bet: -1.00) -- Bold Suitor, Appleby Mall Accountants Handicap Stakes (01 Oct 26)Running: -10.50 (this bet: -1.00) -- Black Cab, Position Payout At bet365 Handicap Stakes (01 Oct 26)Running: -11.50 (this bet: -1.00) -- Arlecchino's Rex, bet365 Apprentice Handicap Stakes (01 Oct 26)Running: -12.50 (this bet: -1.00) -- Perfect Hope, H. Malone & Sons 100th Anniversary Nursery Handicap Stakes (02 Oct 26)Running: -9.17 (this bet: +3.33) -- Quiet Summer, Nuvo Audit Handicap Stakes (GBBPlus Race) (02 Oct 26)Running: -10.17 (this bet: -1.00) -- Haltonwood, Henry Malone 1926 Handicap Stakes (Div II) (02 Oct 26)Running: -11.17 (this bet: -1.00) -- Berkshire Boom, Unibet Supports Safer Gambling Handicap Stakes (London Mile Series Qualifier) (04 Oct 26)Running: -12.17 (this bet: -1.00) -- Kondratiev Wave, Set Your Limits With Unibet Handicap Stakes (04 Oct 26)Running: -13.17 (this bet: -1.00) -- Ground Force, Origin Amenity Solutions Nursery Handicap Stakes (04 Oct 26)Running: -14.17 (this bet: -1.00) -- Free World, Always Trying Racing Syndicate Handicap Stakes (04 Oct 26)Running: -15.17 (this bet: -1.00) -- Roman Spring, Download The Matchbook Exchange App Handicap Stakes (06 Oct 26)Running: -16.17 (this bet: -1.00) -- Silver Trumpet, Try Unibet's New Improved Acca Boosts Apprentice Handicap Stakes (07 Oct 26)Running: -17.17 (this bet: -1.00) -- Brighton View, Watch Racing TV Now Handicap Stakes (Div I) (GBBPlus Race) (07 Oct 26)Running: -18.17 (this bet: -1.00) -- Nanoscience, HKJC World Pool Handicap Stakes (09 Oct 26)Running: -19.17 (this bet: -1.00) -- Eightthreeone, Pepsi Max Handicap Stakes (Div II) (10 Oct 26)Running: -20.17 (this bet: -1.00) -- Navy Waters, SIS, Supporting Irish Racing Fillies Handicap (11 Oct 26)Running: -21.17 (this bet: -1.00) -- Rory's Royale, Unibet More Extra Place Races Handicap Stakes (12 Oct 26)Running: -22.17 (this bet: -1.00) -- Fairydale, Racing TV Handicap Stakes (12 Oct 26)Running: -23.17 (this bet: -1.00) -- Glenna, Bet £20 Get £20 With Unibet Fillies' Handicap Stakes (London Middle Distance Series Qualifier) (14 Oct 26)Running: -24.17 (this bet: -1.00) -- Oxford Circus, Free Bets On Attheraces.com Apprentice Handicap Stakes (15 Oct 26)
Open bets

Nothing currently unsettled for this strategy.

Race Time Meeting Race Horse Type Odds Finished Result Profit
Thu 15 Oct, 16:30 Southwell Free Bets On Attheraces.com Apprentice Handicap Stakes Oxford Circus WIN 7/2 5 LOST -1.00
Wed 14 Oct, 20:30 Kempton Bet £20 Get £20 With Unibet Fillies' Handicap Stakes (London Middle Distance Series Qualifier) Glenna WIN 3/1 2 LOST -1.00
Mon 12 Oct, 20:15 Kempton Unibet More Extra Place Races Handicap Stakes Rory's Royale WIN 3/1 3 LOST -1.00
Mon 12 Oct, 16:50 Musselburgh Racing TV Handicap Stakes Fairydale WIN 5/1 8 LOST -1.00
Sun 11 Oct, 17:25 Naas SIS, Supporting Irish Racing Fillies Handicap Navy Waters WIN 9/2 5 LOST -1.00
Sat 10 Oct, 19:00 Southwell Pepsi Max Handicap Stakes (Div II) Eightthreeone WIN 11/4 2 LOST -1.00
Fri 09 Oct, 17:20 Newmarket HKJC World Pool Handicap Stakes Nanoscience WIN 9/2 4 LOST -1.00
Wed 07 Oct, 17:00 Kempton Try Unibet's New Improved Acca Boosts Apprentice Handicap Stakes Silver Trumpet WIN 9/2 7 LOST -1.00
Wed 07 Oct, 15:59 Nottingham Watch Racing TV Now Handicap Stakes (Div I) (GBBPlus Race) Brighton View WIN 7/2 10 LOST -1.00
Tue 06 Oct, 17:08 Brighton Download The Matchbook Exchange App Handicap Stakes Roman Spring WIN 5/1 6 LOST -1.00
Mon 05 Oct, 19:15 Kempton Set Your Limits With Unibet Handicap Stakes Kondratiev Wave WIN 22/1 9 LOST -1.00
Mon 05 Oct, 16:56 Pontefract Always Trying Racing Syndicate Handicap Stakes Free World WIN 5/2 2 LOST -1.00
Mon 05 Oct, 16:45 Kempton Unibet Supports Safer Gambling Handicap Stakes (London Mile Series Qualifier) Berkshire Boom WIN 5/1 9 LOST -1.00
Mon 05 Oct, 15:00 Yarmouth Origin Amenity Solutions Nursery Handicap Stakes Ground Force WIN 9/4 2 LOST -1.00
Fri 02 Oct, 17:55 Wolverhampton Position Payout At bet365 Handicap Stakes Black Cab WIN 7/1 8 LOST -1.00
Fri 02 Oct, 17:15 Newcastle H. Malone & Sons 100th Anniversary Nursery Handicap Stakes Perfect Hope WIN 4/1 2 LOST -1.00
Fri 02 Oct, 16:55 Wolverhampton Appleby Mall Accountants Handicap Stakes Bold Suitor WIN 20/1 4 LOST -1.00
Fri 02 Oct, 16:40 Newcastle Henry Malone 1926 Handicap Stakes (Div II) Haltonwood WIN 7/2 5 LOST -1.00
Fri 02 Oct, 16:25 Wolverhampton Nuvo Audit Handicap Stakes (GBBPlus Race) Quiet Summer WIN 10/3 1 WON 3.33
Fri 02 Oct, 13:31 Wolverhampton bet365 Apprentice Handicap Stakes Arlecchino's Rex WIN 9/4 7 LOST -1.00
Thu 01 Oct, 15:49 Salisbury Sandown Kia Salisbury Handicap Stakes Regional Rock WIN 5/1 1 WON 5.00
Thu 01 Oct, 13:58 Nottingham Racedays For £9 At Nottingham Racecourse Nursery Handicap Stakes Washington Royale WIN 5/1 3 LOST -1.00
Wed 30 Sep, 17:08 Musselburgh Join Racing Tv Now Handicap Stakes Riddikulus WIN 10/3 2 LOST -1.00
Wed 30 Sep, 15:23 Musselburgh Dropkicks Split The G Nursery Handicap Stakes Rock Steady Beat WIN 9/2 3 LOST -1.00
Tue 29 Sep, 18:07 Bath Carbonnetzero Handicap Stakes (Arab Race) Izenterisky (A) WIN 9/4 3 LOST -1.00
Tue 29 Sep, 17:37 Bath Clyde And Co Handicap Stakes (Div II) Army Bugler WIN 16/1 8 LOST -1.00
Tue 29 Sep, 16:30 Wolverhampton Hotel & Conferencing At Wolverhampton Handicap Stakes Henfield WIN 5/1 5 LOST -1.00
Tue 29 Sep, 15:08 Ayr Nairns's Oatcakes Handicap Stakes (GBBPlus Race) Keep An Eye On It WIN 4/1 2 LOST -1.00
Tue 29 Sep, 14:02 Bath Jdl Consultants Ltd Apprentice Handicap Stakes Decalogue WIN 5/1 5 LOST -1.00
Mon 28 Sep, 15:50 Brighton Matchbook Monthly Bet-Builder Rebate Handicap Stakes Gallant Lion WIN 7/2 4 LOST -1.00
Mon 28 Sep, 15:50 Brighton Matchbook Monthly Bet-Builder Rebate Handicap Stakes Darkest Red WIN 7/2 1 WON 3.50
Sun 27 Sep, 16:32 Epsom Betfred 'The Classic Bookmaker' Handicap Stakes Crown Office WIN 3/1 5 LOST -1.00
Sun 27 Sep, 13:37 Epsom Betfred 'Turbo Boost' Nursery Handicap Stakes The Ginger Kid WIN 10/3 2 LOST -1.00
Sat 26 Sep, 18:30 Southwell Tipsy Tapas At Winter Ladies Evening Handicap Stakes Madjid WIN 5/2 5 LOST -1.00
Sat 26 Sep, 16:50 Newmarket Hunt Family Fund Handicap Stakes Sword Maker WIN 7/2 5 LOST -1.00
Sat 26 Sep, 16:10 Southwell Gent's Night Sat 24th October Handicap Stakes Let's Go Hugo WIN 9/2 2 LOST -1.00
Fri 25 Sep, 16:50 Haydock By Eck Its Boddingtons Handicap Stakes (gbbplus Race) Asia Force WIN 5/2 4 LOST -1.00
Fri 25 Sep, 16:18 Haydock Christopher Ward Watchmaking Handicap Stakes Mr Noble WIN 5/1 11 LOST -1.00
Thu 24 Sep, 16:22 Southwell Weekend Winners On At The Races Handicap Stakes Starakova WIN 4/1 11 LOST -1.00